TPC Gold | 3 vs 4 Bedroom Homes: Which Do Renters Prefer?

In today’s bonus episode, we’re digging into a question from listener Joel, who’s wondering if adding a fourth bedroom will make his place more attractive to Aussie renters. 

Bryce and Ben break down what renters really want in a property – and spoiler alert, it’s all about finding the right balance! They cover why extra bedrooms can be a win, but only if you’re not sacrificing too much living space.  

Plus, they share tips on how suburb trends and layout choices can make all the difference when it comes to attracting tenants. 

If you’re keen to know how to set your rental property up for success, this snippet is packed with insights to help you make the best choice! 

For the full Q&A episode, tune in here: Episode 178 | Q&A: Is that 4th Bedroom Such a Good Idea? APRA’s Effect on Credit Cards & What’s The Secret to a Career in Property Investment? 

__________________

Now That You Know Renters’ Preferences for 3 Vs 4 Bedroom Homes…

We hope these insights help you on your journey to building an investment property portfolio! 

Whether you’re just starting out or looking to sharpen your skills, our book The Armchair Guide to Property Investing is packed with tips to guide you along the way. And the best part? You can grab it for FREE!

If You Enjoyed TPC Gold | 3 vs 4 Bedroom Homes: Which Do Renters Prefer? You Might Also Like:

• Ep 334 | Bernard Salt: The BIG Shift in Australian Property! 
• Ep 458 | Are We At The Turning Point? From Slow Growth To A Surge in Listings – Chat with Tim Lawless 
• Ep 461 | Why AI, Office Culture and Medium Density has the Power to Revolutionise Australia’s Property Market! – Chat with Simon Kuestenmacher 

---

Transcript

Bryce Holdaway
Today’s Q&A Day, we love it. SpeakPipe, we always want our listeners to come and leave us a message. So here, Ivise, is our first one.  

Joel
Hi Bryce, Ben and Stiggy. My name is Joel, I’m from Adelaide, South Australia. The question I’d like to ask is what types of rooms and features do Australians want in the rental market at the moment? The property that I’m looking at is a three-bedroom with an open living area and a large home entertainment room or cinema room. Now looking at the plans, I would probably convert that into a fourth bedroom, add some wardrobes, because it’s quite large. But I don’t know what other Australians would want. So I would live there for a few years before renting it out. But I don’t know, would Australians prefer the fourth bedroom or would they prefer to have a home living area, activities rooms, stuff like that? So any input would be great. Thanks.  

Bryce Holdaway
Very good question, Joel. I would say the first thing, Ben, is my number one rule within looking at something like this is context. What’s the context for the suburb right? If you’ve squeezed in a fourth bedroom and it’s meant a very tiny living area and there’s only one bathroom and the rest of the suburb provides you much better options than that, you’ve really limited your market.  

Ultimately, I took this from Bernard Salt. He wrote the book The Big Shift back in the 90s. I read that. And he goes, Australians, it’s not a Manhattan-isation. We value space. Whenever we have a public holiday, we get the kids in the car, we drive to nature, we go to the bush, the beach, whatever. So we value space. So for me, from the buyer’s end’s perspective, if you can add another bedroom, all things being equal and you haven’t seriously compromised on the living space, it’s just a proven fact that that actually creates value.  

I mean, we have bought properties for clients where there was a precedent where just down the road there was someone with an extra bedroom, made the change, automatically created some equity. So all things being equal, extra bedrooms make a difference, but as long as it’s not coming at the expense of four bedrooms, one bathroom. That’s a nightmare. Or the suburb norm does not support what you’ve done. They’re my two caveats around that.  

Ben Kingsley
Mate, if I lift your message up to the 30,000 (ft) view, look. I think of it like a pyramid, right? So I come back to this owner-occupier appeal piece, and I say this in terms of trying to explain it. If there was a, let’s say there was a glut of properties in the marketplace. I’m talking, for whatever reason, half of our population was wiped out tomorrow, right? And that would mean that obviously rents would be at a premium. I mean, everyone would worry about why the population got wiped out. Might have been a war, you know… 

Bryce Holdaway
Collingwood premiership. 

Ben Kingsley
But just think of it like this. It’s as simple for me as what would be my preference from an owner-occupier. So if the price came down on a Toorak mansion that I could rent for 500 bucks a week, would I rent it? Yep. Because it gives me convenience, it gives me access, it gives me everything. So I always, when I’m looking at buying property, think about the owner-occupier appeal for the renter because the renter wants all the things that an owner-occupier wants.  

They don’t think necessarily like a renter. They don’t say, because I’m a renter, I don’t want this, I don’t want that. There might be an argument where they don’t want to do gardens, but that’s about it. But if you give me a four-bedroom, two-bathroom home for the same price I can do a unit in the same suburb, most people are gonna go for the four-bedroom home. Now that’s not possible because the four-bedroom home’s probably worth double and would charge a premium rent. Now that rent is set by demand and supply. And the only reason we can command a rent of that level is because of the appeal, the demand.  

So Joel, coming back to your question, if it’s got an extra room, that extra room could be a sewing room, it could be a storeroom, it could be a bedroom, it could be a study, it could be all of those things to those different people. So, Bryce summed it up beautifully by saying, we will take the extra space so long as it’s within our budget. Okay, and normally if you do get that extra space, you do get a little bit more extra rent because you’re providing more dwelling accommodation. You’re providing more residents under which you’re able to charge that out. So the bigger the property, the more bang for buck you’re going to get from a rental point of view and it’s as simple as that. So don’t try and get too caught up in: this is perfect for a single person with a dog or this is perfect for a couple who are studying at university.  

The big caveat for me, I always try and say, if you have to go and settle for an apartment, try and make sure that the toilet is outside of the bathroom. People think about that stuff. They think about the fact that if someone’s got a stomach-ache or whatever, but they’ve got to have a shower to get to work, they can’t go in there because someone’s ill on the toilet. Right. It’s little things like that that make all the difference. So a mandate for me is that.  

Bryce Holdaway
Including if you’re buying a one-bedroom apartment too, Ben.  

Ben Kingsley
Totally.  

Bryce Holdaway
Because imagine if you’ve got friends over for dinner and they’ve gotta go through your bedroom to actually go to the toilet. 

Ben Kingsley
Yeah, and you know if I’m looking at an apartment, I like apartments that really are more than 55 square meters in size because I want sort of a dining area. I want an area that I can put a table to sit down that’s not in my living room, that I’ve just got to sit on my sofa to watch the television. So that’s a big thing for me. The separate laundry is a big bonus and that’s what normally happens. The bigger space but that’s why you pay a premium for it. So it still comes back to the whole fundamental of you will get more rent for something that has more demand.  

Bryce Holdaway
The message here is don’t over-complicate it. If you can move something from a two to a three bedroom, that’s got enormous power. Three to four, it’s great for families. Four to five? Not so much, maybe.  

Ben Kingsley
No. But if you’re offering me the four to five, if you’re offering me a five-bedroom home at a four-bedroom price as a tenant, because the market might be soft at that time…guess what? The tenant’s more likely to take the five – better to put the surfboards in or to put the bikes in or to put whatever, because it’s more storage.  

Bryce Holdaway
But as the investor you want to appeal to the tenant, you also want to make it a return on investment.  

Ben Kingsley
Correct. So if you’ve paid an absolute premium for the fifth and sixth bedroom and you’re not going to get that return, that’s when it starts to taper off.  

Bryce Holdaway
Good question. We appreciate that, Joel. Thank you; hopefully that’s helped. Let us know. Send us an email. Let us know if that hit the mark for you.